Jump to content

 
Photo

1973 map design MA thesis: abstract, intro, pdf link (precursor to Cahill-Keyes World Map)

- - - - - Cahill-Keyes Cahill-Keyes World Map B.J.S. Cahill Buckminster Fuller Map Scales MA Thesis Geocells Graticule Megamap Projections

  • Please log in to reply
2 replies to this topic

#1
Gene Keyes

Gene Keyes

    Contributor

  • Validated Member
  • PipPip
  • 27 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Berwick, Nova Scotia
  • Interests:world politics, world peace, world map cartography, B.J.S. Cahill, Buckminster Fuller, Robert Heinlein, Esperanto
  • Canada

Precursor to the Cahill-Keyes World Map:


Full-text pdf of 1973 MA thesis by Gene Keyes
(see new abstract and introduction below)

SIX PRINCIPLES FOR A UNIFIED MAP SYSTEM
(Applied to the China-Russia Situation)


in its original 232-page typescript plus 49 map dummies

For Master of Arts at Southern Illinois University, Carbondale
Government Department
1973 August


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

As reprinted 2017-03-15

 

Abstract, 1973-08-10 MA thesis

 

Six Principles for a Unified Map System
(Applied to the China-Russia Situation)

by Gene Keyes
Carbondale: Southern Illinois University, Government Dept.
232 p. + 49 maps
(abstract added to pdf reprint 2017-03-15)
 

Most world maps are notoriously distorted and open-ended. Most other political-historical maps are a chaos of unrelated projections and perspectives, scales and sizes, grids and graticules, shapes and formats: orphans with no complete parent world map nor globe. Regional sections focus on Europe or America; shrink Africa and Asia. So-called "authoritative" political maps are seldom available, except as secret weapons of international conflict. Thus, geopolitical ignorance remains endemic, however well-drawn a particular map, series, or atlas.

To facilitate comprehension of the entire earth as a finite frame of natural and human events, a "Unified World Map System" is herewith propounded. All of its sub-squares are based on the same Master World Profile* in a specified scale progression from tiny to giant; at constant sizes, perspectives, and graticules; with resolution of 1° or at least 5°; and formatted so that hierarchical miniatures relate all main maps and globes in the system to one another: the whole earth to the street where you live. All panels belong to a millimeter matrix on a proposed 1/1,000,000 "Megamap" version 40 meters long, and its correlates: reduced, enlarged, or detached.

 

The thesis begins with a critique of political cartography and historical atlases; then elaborates its six principles: 1) Scale; 2) Projection; 3) Shape; 4) Size; 5) Perspective; and 6) Format. The map supplement includes a test sequence using hand, photocopy, and computer-drawn maps (20 cm) to show China and Russia together at 1/50,000,000, from 2000 BC to 1950 AD (19 panels), and zeroes in to Chenpao / Damansky Island at 1/5,000, the site of their almost-nuclear-war in 1969 (20 panels).

 

* [at first, Buckminster Fuller's map; since the thesis, a redesigned Cahill projection.]

 

Note: a later version of the abstract, discussed below in the Introduction to the pdf reprint, adds four more principles for a potentially revised edition entitled “Ten Principles for a Coherent World Map System”.



2017-03-15
Gene Keyes
Introduction to the reprint-original of my 1973 MA thesis


Note: while the pdf can be directly downloaded from here I suggest you read these introductory remarks first.

I had hoped to make a searchable reprint of the thesis, but OCR was so klutzy, and ditto the voice-dictation of Google docs, that I settled for mere jpeg scans of the original pages, gathered into a pdf. I had even tried keyboarding the ms anew for a couple of pages, but that would have meant a constant temptation to revise the thing entirely, and was too daunting anyway. So here is the original, warts and all, produced on a Foxit Phantom pdf composer.

The warts are mainly in the 49-page map supplement, which comprises 8" x 8" dummies, plus an array of insets, none of which were polished to begin with; only intended to illustrate the various principles. Worse yet, their original artwork had deteriorated since 1973. Back then, I did not know one should never use rubber cement! After such a long time, it had dried, lost adhesion, and stained many of the separate pieces. Also, Xerox in those days could not do color; nor jet black, only a washed out grey. I did not re-make the maps, but have tried to partially "restore" them; adding color, and in some cases a few enhancements. The results are still dummies, not high-quality graphics.
 
As of now, it has been 44 years since this thesis was drafted. Certain parts are outdated or superseded, but much remains relevant. Foremost among the changes I made subsequently is in regard to the "Projection" principle: Less than two years after completing my ms, I discarded the 1954 Fuller icosahedral world map, and adapted the 1909 B.J.S. Cahill octahedral instead.

Till then, in the thesis I was striving mightily to make Buckminster Fuller's  Dymaxion projection the all purpose base world map for geopolitical affairs, or any other educational intent. At the last minute, I found that the Dymaxion had too many shortcomings. So as a provisional expedient, I depicted my 19 joint historical maps of Russia and China, not on Fuller's, but on an orthographic [sphere-like] projection, marked by me a la Fuller's icosahedral triangles.

Yet this was so unsatisfactory that after the thesis had been submitted, I began to realize B.J.S. Cahilll's 1909 octahedral design would have been far better for my purposes. While I had discussed his map in the thesis, its "Butterfly" shape did not seem suitable for the all-encompassing world map I sought;  e.g., for horizontal close-ins of any area.
 
Then in March 1975, I reoriented Cahill's octants into an "M" shape: Eureka! Just the map I had been hoping for, with a more-or-less "horizontal" aspect. [Not that there is any "right side up" for a map; but that's another story. Also, I later found out Cahill himself, had depicted an M-layout, but not used it; his whole stock-in-trade was the Butterfly.]


    Cahill-Pacific-1920-.jpg             C-K-silh-A-B-Scale-C.jpg
                                             Cahill 1909                                                             Cahill-Keyes 1975


Cahill's cartography had been all but forgotten, and I could not find any off-the-shelf maps of his to work with. So by November 1975, I had devised my own Cahill-Keyes version from scratch, with various tweaks and a brand new graticule. (I also did much research on his originals and variations. Both his design and mine are elaborated in great detail and profusely illustrated on my website, www.genekeyes.com, including an extensive comparison / critique of the Cahill and Fuller maps, and much else.)

That is how the thesis is the precursor to the Cahill-Keyes World map, because the C-K accomplishes what I had so vainly tried to make of the Dymaxion: a multi-purpose, multi-scale Megamap, in macro vistas and micro, all from the same Master Map at 1/1,000,000. As well, the Cahill-Keyes is a much better fit in the System itself, dovetailing more precisely with the other principles.

Meanwhile, in composing an abstract, which had not accompanied the thesis, I eventually updated it to add four more principles which emerged in the course of my design work on the Cahill-Keyes world map: Geocells; Graticule; Grid; and Global Fidelity, These were all inherent in the thesis, but I decided to elevate them to "principles" in their own right. Briefly, these are the additional ones:

1) Geocells: Is the term I coined in 1983 for an area bounded by one degree of latitude and longitude. All geocells are to be reasonably proportionate to one another throughout the entire map, and all geocells are to be shown in a Cahill-Keyes system map. The principle is amplified in its corollary, graticule:

2) Graticule: I placed great emphasis on the need for world maps and globes to show a one-degree, or at least a five-degree graticule (latitude and longitude net). This principle emphasizes its visibility, symmetry, regularity, and proportionality: criteria altogether lacking in Fuller's map; and conventional world maps; and to a lesser extent, even in Cahill's earlier versions.

3) Grid: The system's nexus is the 1/1,000,000 Megamap, a Master World Profile inscribed precisely in the length of a 40,000 x 20,000 millimeter grid, representing the unrolled 40,000 km circumference of the Earth. [This principle achieved vivid proof-of-concept in 2011, when Mary Jo Graça wrote a Perl program and OpenOffice Draw script for a Cahill-Keyes World Map of that scale and scope in a pdf occupying almost 9.000 square feet (800 square meters), but which can be easily panned, viewed, and re-sized in a Foxit pdf reader:                              


4) Global Fidelity: is [A] similitude of continents on a [Cahill-Keyes] flat map to those on a globe: a  quality blatantly lacking in most other world maps; and [B] a synoptic globe / map partnership, in which the point-for-point pairings of loci on a map and globe are instantly comparable to one another: i.e., octant plus one-degree marked globes exactly corresponding to the octant plus one-degree layout of a Cahill-Keyes map at the same scale.

These principles, as well as the original six, have a lot more underlying detail. (See my website.) So for those willing to travel back, back, to the days before the Internet and the personal computer, I now offer my original typewritten 1973 MA thesis via the Internet, as reproduced on my home computers: an OS 9 Mac and a Windows 7 PC, with Foxit Phantom pdf composer, an HP 1210 All-in-One printer-copier-scanner; Netscape 7 html Composer; OpenOffice 4; and ClarisWorks 5. (Even all that hard-and-software of mine is getting long in the tooth; but I digress.)

What follows are jpegs of the table of contents, and illustration list, from the thesis. And as mentioned, the entire thesis pdf can be viewed or downloaded from here.

Gene Keyes
Berwick, Nova Scotia, Canada
2017-03-15

toc.jpg

loi.jpg

vi.jpg

quote.jpg

 



#2
Gene Keyes

Gene Keyes

    Contributor

  • Validated Member
  • PipPip
  • 27 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Berwick, Nova Scotia
  • Interests:world politics, world peace, world map cartography, B.J.S. Cahill, Buckminster Fuller, Robert Heinlein, Esperanto
  • Canada

Excuse the duplicate upload here; I was trying to edit out a single excess parenthesis in the title; a whole new duplicate topic got uploaded; and I can't find a "delete" button for the erroneous one.  —GK



#3
Hans van der Maarel

Hans van der Maarel

    CartoTalk Editor-in-Chief

  • Admin
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 4,155 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:The Netherlands
  • Interests:Cartography, GIS, history, popular science, music.
  • Netherlands

No problem Gene, I deleted the duplicate one. Thanks for sharing this!


Hans van der Maarel - Cartotalk Editor
Red Geographics
Email: hans@redgeographics.com / Twitter: @redgeographics





Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: Cahill-Keyes, Cahill-Keyes World Map, B.J.S. Cahill, Buckminster Fuller, Map Scales, MA Thesis, Geocells, Graticule, Megamap, Projections

0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users

-->